Skip to main content

Table 1 Comparative patient demographics, medical presentation, hospital, and surgeon characteristics prior to propensity score matching (PSM)a

From: A retrospective study of laparoscopic, robotic-assisted, and open emergent/urgent cholecystectomy based on the PINC AI Healthcare Database 2017–2020

Parameter

Overall (n = 233,945)

RAC (n = 10,019)

Open (n = 2687)

Laparoscopic (n = 221,239)

Age groups, n (%)

 18–44 years

82,449 (35.0)

3701 (37.0)

379 (14.0)

78,369 (35.0)

 45–64 years

76,079 (33.0)

3272 (33.0)

852 (32.0)

71,955 (33.0)

 65+ years

75,417 (32.0)

3046 (30.0)

1456 (54.0)

70,915 (32.0)

Sex, n (%)

 Female

143,136 (61.0)

6172 (62.0)

1261 (47.0)

135,703 (61.0)

 Male

90,809 (39.0)

3847 (38.0)

1426 (53.0)

85,536 (39.0)

Obesity, n (%)

 BMI < 30, kg/m2

4618 (2.0)

185 (1.8)

187 (7.0)

4246 (1.9)

 BMI 30–34, kg/m2

17,532 (7.5)

882 (8.8)

178 (6.6)

16,472 (7.5)

 BMI 35–39, kg/m2

15,662 (6.7)

786 (7.8)

138 (5.1)

14,738 (6.7)

 BMI ≥ 40, kg/m2

22,014 (9.4)

1166 (12.0)

243 (9.0)

20,605 (9.3)

 BMI unknown

174,119 (74.0)

7000 (70.0)

1941 (72.0)

165,178 (75.0)

Ethnicity, n (%)

 Hispanic or Latino

37,231 (16.0)

1960 (20.0)

282 (10.0)

34,989 (16.0)

 Not Hispanic or Latino

152,365 (65.0)

6311 (63.0)

1945 (72.0)

144,109 (65.0)

 Unknown

44,349 (19.0)

1748 (17.0)

460 (17.0)

42,141 (19.0)

Race, n (%)

 Caucasian

169,904 (73.0)

7354 (73.0)

1988 (74.0)

160,552 (73.0)

 Black

22,393 (9.6)

889 (8.9)

277 (10.0)

21,227 (9.6)

 Other

27,186 (12.0)

1263 (13.0)

255 (9.5)

25,668 (12.0)

 Unknown

14,462 (6.2)

513 (5.1)

157 (5.8)

13,792 (6.2)

Primary diagnosis category, n (%)

 Gangrene and perforation

107 (< 0.1)

8 (< 0.1)

2 (< 0.1)

97 (< 0.1)

 CBD stones and disease

41,358 (18.0)

1719 (17.0)

403 (15.0)

39,236 (18.0)

 Cholecystitis w/o CBD stones

152,139 (65.0)

6484 (65.0)

1363 (51.0)

144,292 (65.0)

 Biliary pancreatitis

21,161 (9.0)

1007 (10.0)

129 (4.8)

20,025 (9.1)

 Bacteremia/sepsis

19,180 (8.2)

801 (8.0)

790 (29.0)

17,589 (8.0)

Charlson Comorbidity Score, n (%)

 CCI = 0

127,394 (54.0)

5184 (52.0)

955 (36.0)

121,255 (55.0)

 CCI = 1

56,902 (24.0)

2605 (26.0)

624 (23.0)

53,673 (24.0)

 CCI ≥ 2

49,649 (21.0)

2330 (22.0)

1108 (41.0)

46,311 (21.0)

Census region, n (%)

 Midwest

43,094 (18.0)

1524 (15.0)

488 (18.0)

41,082 (19.0)

 Northeast

34,507 (15.0)

467 (6.0)

504 (19.0)

33,436 (15.0)

 South

106,318 (45.0)

5296 (53.0)

1252 (47.0)

9970 (45.0)

 West

50,026 (21.0)

2632 (26.0)

443 (16.0)

46,951 (21.0)

Admission year, n (%)

 2017

62,112 (27.0)

1663 (17.0)

814 (30.0)

59,635 (27.5)

 2018

62,018 (27.0)

1938 (19.0)

716 (27.0)

59,364 (27.0)

 2019

61,540 (26.0)

2718 (27.0)

655 (24.0)

58,167 (26.0)

 2020

48,275 (21.0)

3700 (37.0)

502 (19.0)

44,073 (20.0)

Admission type, n (%)

 Inpatient

200,582 (86.0)

8288 (83.0)

2659 (99.0)

189,635 (86.0)

 Outpatient

7424 (3.2)

534 (5.3)

4 (0.1)

6886 (3.1)

 Outpatient observation < 24 h

25,939 (11.0)

1197 (12.0)

24 (0.9)

24,718 (11.0)

Hospital size, n (%)

 0–199 beds

54,166 (23.0)

2058 (21.0)

547 (20.0)

51,561 (23.0)

 200–299 beds

44,121 (19.0)

2795 (28.0)

400 (15.0)

40,926 (18.0)

 300–399 beds

40,393 (17.0)

1626 (16.0)

521 (19.0)

38,246 (17.0)

 400–499 beds

27,816 (12.0)

1009 (10.0)

312 (12.0)

26,495 (12.0)

 500+ beds

67,449 (29.0)

2531 (25.0)

907 (34.0)

64,011 (29.0)

Physician specialty, n (%)

 General and colorectal surgery

222,103 (95.0)

9679 (96.6)

2480 (92.3)

209,944 (95.0)

 Trauma and critical care surgery

11,842 (5.1)

340 (3.4)

207 (7.7)

11,295 (5.0)

Cholecystectomy volume 1 year prior to index surgery, n (%)

 High volume groupb

78,559 (34.0)

4156 (41.0)

727 (27.0)

73,676 (33.0)

 Medium volume groupc

86,947 (37.0)

3765 (38.0)

1074 (40.0)

82,108 (37.0)

 Low volume groupd

68,439 (29.0)

2098 (21.0)

886 (33.0)

65,455 (30.0)

  1. PSM = Propensity score matching; RAC = Robotic-assisted cholecystectomy; SD = Standard deviation of the mean; BMI = Body mass index; CCI = Charlson Comorbidity Index
  2. aCovariates for matching were: age, sex, BMI, ethnicity, race, census region, presence of comorbidities, and CCI score
  3. bMedian number of procedures = 105
  4. cMedian number of procedures = 45
  5. dMedian number of procedures = 10